I'm kinda late to the party but I just found about this thread and I just wanted to write this prompt! :) I know what you mean about not many fanfiction on the site anymore, and I tried too to make these kind of threads to encourage people to write, I hope this one helps people!
“But how do I tell him that I love him?” the redhead asked, worry set deep in her eyes. “Sinead, why don’t you just tell him what you told me?” Jonah replied, a laughter faintly present in his eyes. Immediately, the girl felt guilty. It wasn’t exactly proper to ask your ex-boyfriend for advice on your new relationship.
Sinead hugged her legs and buried her face in her hands. It had been almost half a year since she and Jonah had broken up, but that strange feeling was still there, even if they both acted like everything was okay. Even if they had broken up because they had both agreed that they were better off friends, than a couple, it was still weird.
Why did Hamilton have to be Jonah's best friend? Why were things so complicated?
She groaned and rubbed her eyes. "I mean we've been together for about a month now...isn't it too rushed to say 'I love you'?"
Jonah looked away and another wave of guilt hit Sinead. Why did they start this conversation in the first place? Stupid, stupid Sinead!, the redhead thought and mentally punched herself.
"Look" Jonah started "Ham likes you a lot; I can tell. So, if you feel that way, I don't think that it is a bad thing to tell him. I mean he is your boyfriend..."
Silence. Sinead recalled the moment she and Hamilton went over to Jonah and told him that something had happened between them. The truth was, that they wanted his permission. And Jonah had smiled and said that everything was fine and that it was perfectly okay, since his relationship with Sinead was in the past.
But Sinead couldn't forget how broken that smile was.
She slowly stood up from his couch and started grabbing her stuff. "I'm sorry I came here, I'll just leave now, I mean Amy was busy and I didn't know where to go and-"
Oh god, she was rambling again.
"Sinead." He stood up and grabbed her arms. "It's okay. Nothing is wrong. Everything is fine."
She looked at him and felt her eyes going blurry. Did she hurt him when she started going out with Hamilton? Jonah's thumbs slowly started gently caressing her arms.
"Uh-I have to go. Thanks for...the conversation" she said under her breath and before he could say anything she rushed herself out of his apartment.
She hadn't realized how long she had been walking. The only thing she knew was that it was night now. She wrapped her arms around her body and tried to control the shake of her body. It wasn't freezing, but it was cold enough for her to shiver, because the shirt she was wearing was too thin to make her warm.
She felt desperate. Did Jonah still feel something for her? Did she keep hurting him this way?
Two raindrops fell on her head and then it started to rain. You must be kidding me. She felt her clothes sticking on her body but didn't move to cover herself. She just let it and raised her head about to face the rainy, night sky.
Until she heard someone screaming her name. With teary eyes and mascara running on her cheeks, she turned around and saw Hamilton running towards her. Her heart started beating faster the more he came closer.
"Sinead!" he shouted again and reached her. He grabbed her shoulders. "What are you doing out here? Why aren't you answering your phone?" he was shouting.
"Do you have any idea how worried I was?" His hair was wet and his clothes were sticking on his body as well. But the expression on his face just screamed one thing.
Worry. He seemed worried sick about her. And Sinead couldn't hold her tears anymore.
"I-I'm sorry, H-Hamilton" she sobbed and dropped her face on her hands. She slowly felt strong arms wrapping around her body and after a few moments, she felt his lips on her forehead.
"I thought something happened to you, and I called, and you weren't answering-god, don't ever do this to me again, Sinead..."
And that was the moment she felt it. That was where she belonged.
In Hamilton's hug.
LONG POST AGAIN SORRYYY!!! :3 Hope it's okay though although it's kinda rushed.